Scandinavians bet model will cushion blow from robot takeover

Register now

(Bloomberg) -- Are you in charge of a government and worried about how to save millions of jobs from the threat of automation? Nordea Bank AB has the answer: just do as the Scandinavians.

According to the latest Economic Outlook by the region’s largest bank, the best way to future-proof your economy is to have a highly educated workforce and low inequality -- two features that abound in the Nordics.

“A lot of work will be replaced by robots,” Nordea senior economist Erik Bruce said in an interview. “The difference is that we're better prepared because we share the view that we should have a fair distribution of income and we make sure people are trained to take on a new role.”

His main advice to policy makers? “Free education probably isn't the only solution, but it's a good start.”

Bruce and his colleague Joachim Bernhadsen cite various studies predicting how millions of jobs will be wiped out due to automation. But the two analysts conclude that, rather than worry about what they call the impending "robocalypse," governments should roll out the welcome mat to the robots.

As the authors point out, the fear that machines will make humans obsolete in the workplace is hardly new (the term "Luddite," which describes people who resist technological change, derives from a group of textile workers who destroyed machinery in 19th century England). They also take issue with the basic assumption behind some of the more alarmist studies, namely that the next industrial revolution will destroy many more jobs than it will create. Rather, they argue that it will unravel at a more modest pace than many anticipate, and will follow a familiar pattern -- transforming, rather than eliminating, many of the workers’ tasks at risk.

There is a catch, however.

To make the most of automation, governments need to ensure high standards of education and encourage life-long learning, since both allow workers who fall out of the labor market to be easily re-trained. The second, and perhaps more controversial aspect, is to minimize inequality. The analysts cite a 2015 study by David Autor that suggests computers and the Internet have already had "a material effect on income distribution in the U.S." by favoring highly-skilled labor.

Here’s how Finland and Scandinavia fare on the two issues:

On education, not only do they beat the OECD average in terms of PISA scores, they also have an excellent track record at promoting life-long learning. There are no college fees in the Nordics, and just about anyone can afford to study thanks to the safety net of the welfare state. In Denmark, for instance, students aged above 20 receive a monthly stipend of 6,000 kroner ($953) from the state.

In terms of income inequality, it will come as no surprise to learn that the region with some of the highest income tax rates in the world scores particularly well.

If it’s evidence that you need, just look at how globalization has impacted the Nordics. Not only have these small, export-oriented economies been enriched by the rise of free trade, they’ve also so far been spared much of the resulting social unrest witnessed elsewhere.

“Experience from the last 20 years clearly shows that the Nordic model promotes social mobility and equal opportunities,” the analysts conclude in Nordea’s Economic Outlook. “With the right policies, societies can address the distributional consequences of new technology. The Nordic countries are particularly well equipped to reap the benefits and meet the challenges from automation.”

Bloomberg News
Automation Artificial intelligence Data management