Ranking the Highest and Lowest Auto Insurance Rates by State

Recent survey results reveal a significant disparity in auto insurance rates across the country.

Insure.com, an online resource targeting consumers, conducted a national survey of car insurance rates by state based on rates for 40-year-old single male driver who commutes 12 miles to work. But, the company points out that a consumer’s driving record is not always the biggest factor in determining prices and found that a number of non-driver-related factors have a significant effect on the average cost of car insurance for consumers in different states.

The percentage of uninsured drivers in a given state, along with other factors such as weather and state insurance laws, are in large part what determine the average cost of auto insurance premiums.

“We often think of car insurance prices strictly in terms of our own personal details, like our driving record and our coverage amount,” says Amy Danise, senior managing editor of Insure.com. “But Insure.com’s rankings demonstrate how factors like state laws and the judicial system can be the driving force behind high rates.”

The national average annual premium is $1,561. Michigan holds the spot as the most expensive place for auto insurance because it’s the only state that guarantees unlimited personal injury protection payments by law, which is very costly for insurance companies, Insure.com says. Louisiana is the second most expensive state because of its judicial system, which generally favors individuals—meaning that insurance companies tend to lose in court, again driving up costs for insurers. By comparison, a representative driver in Vermont pays 87% less for insurance coverage than the same driver in Michigan because of the lower level of traffic congestion in Vermont and the large number of insurers competing for business.

Below are the U.S. states and the District of Columbia as ranked by the average annual premium that a representative driver would pay:

1. Michigan, $2,541

2. Louisiana, $2,453

3. Oklahoma, $2,197

4. Montana, $2,190

5. Washington, D.C., $2,146

6. California, $1,991

7. Mississippi, $1,896

8. New Mexico, $1,896

9. Arkansas, $1,836

10. Maryland, $1,807

11. North Dakota, $1,794

12. Connecticut, $1,786

13. Rhode Island, $1,747

14. Wyoming, $1,714

15. Hawaii, $1,707

16. South Dakota, $1,707

17. Georgia, $1,670

18. New Jersey, $1,663

19. West Virginia, $1,633

20. Kentucky, $1,629

21. New York, $1,627

22. Minnesota, $1,614

23. Washington, $1,584

24. Missouri, $1,563

25. Indiana, $1,518

26. Colorado, $1,508

27. Texas, $1,492

28. Delaware, $1,489

29. Florida, $1,476

30. Nebraska, $1,470

31. Pennsylvania, $1,468

32. Kansas, $1,461

33. Alaska, $1,454

34. New Hampshire, $1,334

35. Massachusetts, $1,328

36. Idaho, $1,325

37. Alabama, $1,306

38. Oregon, $1,306

39. Nevada, $1,300

40. Illinois, $1,290

41. Arizona, $1,280

42. Utah, $1,272

43. Virginia, $1,237

44. Iowa, $1,179

45. North Carolina, $1,154

46. Ohio, $1,152

47. Tennessee, $1,146

48. Wisconsin, $1,128

49. Maine, $1,126

50. South Carolina, $1,095

51. Vermont, $995

For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.
Core systems Policy adminstration
MORE FROM DIGITAL INSURANCE