AI is changing insurance strategies for small businesses

Laptop computer and coffee mugs on a table in a business setting.
Adobe Stock.

Artificial intelligence has powered the back offices of the insurance industry for years—flagging fraud, streamlining claims and crunching risk data. But now it's stepping into the spotlight. For small businesses, especially those with niche or hybrid models, AI is changing how coverage is offered, purchased and understood. It's bringing clarity to an industry long known for its complexity—and that shift couldn't come at a better time. With AI-driven tools, insurance is becoming more accessible, transparent, and tailored to the needs of modern entrepreneurs.

From complexity to clarity: The impact of AI-powered tools

Buying insurance isn't easy. A general contractor might not know whether they need general liability, professional liability, or both. A part-time dog groomer could be unsure about what counts as property coverage versus professional protection. In fact, a recent survey by Simply Business of 1,000 small business owners found that one of the most confusing aspects of insurance is simply figuring out which policies they need—and what those policies actually cover.

That's where AI comes in. AI-powered tools are helping insurers deliver fast, personalized recommendations based on real business needs. Algorithms can now break down coverage in plain language, making it easier for business owners to understand their options.

Imagine a yoga instructor asking a chatbot about liability—and getting a clear, conversational explanation that distinguishes between a slip-and-fall in the studio (general liability) and advice that results in injury (professional liability).

This shift isn't just about simplifying language. It's about helping business owners feel confident that their policies are right for them. By cutting through jargon and guesswork, AI is making insurance feel less like a gamble and more like a well-informed decision.

Making space for the in-between

Today's entrepreneurs don't always fit neatly into a traditional category. Some are part of the gig economy. Others run microbusinesses out of their homes. Still others blend multiple income streams—like a home baker who sells directly to customers and wholesales to local cafés.

Conventional underwriting models often miss these nuances. AI doesn't. By analyzing how a business actually operates, AI helps insurers classify customers more accurately—and recommend coverage that reflects the real-world risks they face.

Take that home baker, for example. While they might describe themselves as a caterer, their primary business activity happens in their kitchen, not at events. AI can flag this distinction, ensuring they get a home-based food business policy rather than coverage designed for event-based work. This level of specificity prevents underinsurance and improves customer satisfaction.

An industry report report found that the use of AI reduces disputes by ensuring better coverage alignment. More importantly, this usage reflects a broader shift: it enables a move away from one-size-fits-all policies toward insurance that adapts to how people actually do business.

A smarter, simpler future strategy with AI

As AI continues to evolve, the entire insurance experience will feel more like a real-time conversation and less like a bureaucratic maze. The next generation of small business owners—especially digital natives from Gen Z and younger Millennials—already expect this kind of seamless, personalized experience in most, if not all, of their consumer experiences.

Recommendation engines are getting smarter. Chatbots are becoming more responsive. In the future, buying insurance could feel as easy as messaging a friend for advice.

Still, as AI becomes more central to the customer journey, the industry must approach its use with care. Bias in AI models is a real concern, particularly in underwriting and risk assessment. Transparency and oversight are critical—not just to avoid compliance issues, but to build and maintain trust with customers.

Small businesses thrive when they are empowered to make informed decisions about their coverage without unnecessary friction. As AI advances, insurers have an opportunity—and an obligation—to meet entrepreneurs where they are, offering clarity, speed, and personalized protection for an increasingly diverse and dynamic economy.

The insurance industry is no stranger to data and automation, but the future belongs to those who use AI to bridge the gap between complexity and accessibility. We see AI as a way to meet customers where they are. That means demystifying coverage, surfacing the right policies, and making it easier than ever for small business owners to protect what they've built.

For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here.
Artificial intelligence Insurtech Buying Insurance Agents
MORE FROM DIGITAL INSURANCE