When we founded ForMotiv eight years ago, nearly every conversation centered on direct-to-consumer digital transformation. Carriers wanted better visibility into online quoting behavior to improve underwriting precision, detect fraud, and increase conversion.
That focus remains. But over the past year, something notable has shifted.
For the first time in our history, we signed more carriers for agent-focused behavioral initiatives than direct initiatives last year. That shift reflects a broader industry realization: if you want to meaningfully improve profitability, prevent leakage and fraud, and increase conversions, you cannot ignore the agent channel.
Agents remain the backbone of property and casualty insurance, placing roughly 62 percent of U.S. P&C premiums and nearly 40 percent of personal lines business, according to the 2025 Big "I" Market Share Report. Yet most carriers still lack consistent visibility into what actually happens inside the quoting, endorsement, and servicing workflows agents use every day.
That blind spot is where both risk and opportunity live.
From Activity Logs to Behavioral Intelligence
Most carriers already capture transactional data: what fields were entered, what coverages were selected, and whether a policy was bound. What is often missing is the behavioral layer. How was the quote completed? Were fields repeatedly toggled? Were discounts applied and removed? Was information edited late in the flow? Did patterns deviate from peer norms?
Those micro-behaviors, when aggregated and contextualized, tell a far richer story than a static application.
We work with several leading carriers, and they're all operationalizing behavioral intelligence at the agent and agency level to quantify risk signals such as:
- Undisclosed drivers
- Young hidden drivers
- Garaging mismatches
- Mileage discrepancies
- Rideshare manipulation
- Coverage toggling patterns
- Ineligible discounting
- Insurance score manipulation
The difference is not simply in collecting more data. It is turning behavioral data into explainable intelligence that flows directly into underwriting, fraud, compliance, and SIU workflows with clear recommended actions. That bridge from data to insight to operational response is what separates experimentation from enterprise value.
Elevating the Agent Experience (AX) Through Precision
There is an important nuance here. Behavioral intelligence is not about adding friction. It is about applying precision and eliminating unnecessary friction.
Historically, carriers have relied on broad rules, static validations, or post-bind audits to manage risk. That approach often creates blanket slowdowns for agents writing clean business while still allowing misrepresented policies to slip through.It also leaves carriers blind to where the quoting experience itself may be creating confusion, rework, or inefficiency.
When behavioral intelligence is embedded into agent portals, friction becomes intentional and targeted. Clean submissions move through smoothly. Elevated-risk behaviors trigger verification or underwriting review. At the same time, aggregated behavioral data reveals where agents hesitate, repeatedly edit fields, toggle coverages, or abandon workflows. Those patterns surface usability gaps, unclear questions, and workflow bottlenecks that can be redesigned to improve the digital experience.
The result is a stronger Agent Experience, or AX, and stronger underwriting discipline at the same time.
In practice, this means:
- Fewer blanket holds
- More transparent underwriting conversations
- Faster processing for high-quality business
- Reduced retroactive corrections and policy rewrites
- Clear visibility into friction points within the application
- Data-driven improvements to quoting and servicing workflows
As carriers compete for productive agents, improving AX is not just about speed. It is about creating a digital environment that is intuitive, predictable, and aligned with how agents actually work. Precision in risk detection and precision in experience design go hand in hand.
Improving AX while protecting profitability is no longer optional.
Benchmarking: From Anecdote to Objective Performance Insight
Another shift we are seeing across top carriers is the move from anecdotal agent management to data-driven benchmarking.
For decades, performance conversations relied heavily on production volume and loss ratio. While essential, those metrics are lagging indicators. They do not explain why performance diverges across agents or agencies.
Behavioral benchmarking changes that dynamic.
By aggregating behavioral patterns across thousands of quoting sessions, carriers can benchmark agents and agencies against their peers on dimensions such as:
- Rate of risk behaviors compared to baseline
- Frequency of discount overrides
- Coverage change patterns
- Quote-to-bind rates and consistency
- Policy edit intensity
This creates an objective framework for identifying outliers, both high-performing and high-risk. Importantly, it allows carriers to separate systemic process issues from individual behavior patterns.For many organizations, this has become the foundation for a new generation of agent scorecards.
Enhancing Agent Scorecards with Behavioral Data
Traditional scorecards focus on production, retention, and loss ratio. Behavioral data introduces leading indicators.
Carriers are now layering behavioral metrics into scorecards to provide a more complete view of agent performance. Instead of reacting to loss trends months later, underwriting and distribution leaders can see early signals tied to misrepresentation risk or operational inefficiencies.
This does not replace existing KPIs. It complements them.
In practice, behavioral-enhanced scorecards help carriers:
- Identify agents who consistently submit clean, accurate business, and those that don't
- Flag patterns that correlate with heightened risk and elevated losses
- Detect compliance risks earlier
- Support more productive performance conversations
The result is a more transparent, data-backed relationship between carrier and agent.
The Financial Stakes Are Clear
In 2016, Verisk reported an estimated $29 billion in annual premium leakage across personal auto. Our estimates have that number materially higher today.
Across our carrier base, Behavioral Intelligence is already delivering measurable outcomes:
- Underwriting Action Rates: Carriers using ForMotiv's Undisclosed Driver solution have seen underwriting action rates as high as 92%+.
- Reclaim Premium & Improve Profitability: Leading carriers are achieving seven to eight-figure profitability gains by attacking loss ratio challenges on two fronts:
- Real-time behavioral actions help reclaim premium dollars that would have otherwise slipped through the cracks
- Underwriting performance is improved by keeping misrepresented or high-risk business off the books
- Agent coaching and compliance: Behavioral benchmarks by agent and agency now drive coaching programs that have cut costly policy changes and drive profitable conversions.
From Innovation Project to Table Stakes
What began as a direct-channel innovation is now expanding into an
The carriers leading this evolution are replacing fragmented views of policyholder and agent behavior with a unified behavioral understanding across the policy lifecycle. This enables more consistent decisioning, stronger compliance oversight, and more efficient distribution management.
As distribution models modernize and margin pressure intensifies, behavioral intelligence is no longer a nice-to-have analytics layer. It is quickly becoming table stakes for carriers that want to protect profitability while strengthening agent relationships.
The industry has always relied on data to price risk. The next frontier is understanding behavior, not just outcomes.
And for many leading carriers, that future is already underway.
Learn more at
